Forage
Eating out with high cholesterol
What to Order at Jersey Mike's for High Cholesterol
Heart-smart Jersey Mike's picks when you're watching your cholesterol — the best subs, the sub-in-a-tub trick, and what to skip.
Jersey Mike's is subs done well, which means the heart-smart path is about choosing leaner proteins over the cured Italian meats, skipping the cheese, and loading the veggies. There's also one great trick: order any sub as a "sub in a tub."
What to look for at Jersey Mike's
Watch the cured/processed meats (salami, capicola, pepperoni, prosciuttini), cheese, mayo, and "Mike's Way" oil + salt. Lean on turkey or grilled chicken, whole-grain bread (or a tub), lots of veggies, and vinegar over mayo.
Heart-smart picks
Oven-roasted turkey or grilled chicken on whole-wheat, no cheese.
"Sub in a tub" — any sub over a bowl of greens instead of bread (cuts refined carbs and sodium).
Load the veggies — lettuce, tomato, onion, peppers, cucumbers.
Red wine vinegar + a little olive oil, easy on the salt, instead of mayo.
Solid runners-up
The grilled chicken (Chipotle Cheese Steak swapped plain) or a turkey sub, veggie-loaded.
A tub version of any lean-protein sub.
What to skip
Italian/cold-cut subs (salami, capicola, pepperoni) — processed-meat sat fat and sodium.
Extra cheese and mayo.
Cheesesteaks with extra cheese, and the full "Mike's Way" salt if watching sodium.
Quick tips
Turkey or grilled chicken, whole-wheat or a tub, all the veggies, vinegar instead of mayo, skip the cheese. That's a genuinely heart-smart sub.
Order the smart sub every time. Forage tells you the best thing to order for your heart at Jersey Mike's or anywhere, and remembers what worked. Join the waitlist.
Forage and this guide offer general wellness guidance, not medical advice. Nutrition varies by location and portion — confirm with the restaurant, and talk to your doctor about your diet.
Stop guessing at the menu.
Join the Forage waitlist and get a heart-smart pick for any menu, remembered for next time.
Join the waitlist
Forage provides estimates to guide your choices and is not medical advice. Consult your doctor.